Debt snowball vs avalanche: which should you use?
The short answer
Avalanche (highest interest rate first) costs the least interest, and is never worse on cost. Snowball (smallest balance first) clears accounts sooner, which helps some people stay the course. If your smallest balance also has your highest rate, they are the same plan. The only way to know the gap is to run your own numbers.
Two payoff orders dominate every conversation about getting out of debt. Both start the same way: pay the minimum on every debt, then pick one debt to attack with everything left over. They differ in a single decision, which debt that is.
The two methods in one minute
Debt snowball. Rank your debts by balance, smallest first. Put all your extra money on the smallest. When it is cleared, add its whole payment to the next smallest. The payment you aim at debt grows as the list shrinks.
Debt avalanche. Rank your debts by interest rate, highest first. Put all your extra money on the highest rate. When it is cleared, move its payment to the next highest rate.
In both cases the minimums on every other debt keep being paid, and a cleared debt’s payment is never spent elsewhere. It rolls forward. That rolling is what makes either method faster than paying each debt in isolation.
Why avalanche is cheaper
Interest is charged every month on what you still owe. A dollar of extra payment removes a dollar of balance, and that dollar would have been charged at the rate of the debt it was on. So the dollar saves the most when it lands on the highest rate. Over the life of the plan, aiming every spare dollar at the most expensive debt first minimises the interest you pay. For fixed rates this is a property of the maths, not an opinion. In Duedown’s tests, avalanche never costs more interest than snowball on randomised sets of debts, apart from a cent or two of rounding.
A worked example
Take three debts and $150 a month of extra money:
| Debt | Balance | APR | Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit card | $5,000 | 24% | $150 |
| Personal loan | $1,500 | 6% | $40 |
| Car loan | $3,000 | 12% | $80 |
| Plan | Debt-free after | Total interest | First debt cleared |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snowball | 29 months | $2,512.79 | Personal loan, month 9 |
| Avalanche | 28 months | $1,850.99 | Credit card, month 21 |
Avalanche saves $661.80 and finishes a month sooner. The price is waiting 21 months for the first debt to disappear, against 9 months with snowball. Snowball is slower here because it spends its early extra money on a 6% loan while the 24% card keeps compounding.
Now change the picture. With the same debts and no extra money at all, the two plans differ by only about $5 of interest and finish in the same month, because nothing is being aimed anywhere. And in a set where the smallest balance is also the most expensive, the two orders are identical. You can try both cases in the debt snowball calculator, which shows both methods side by side for any debts you enter.
What research says about motivation
If avalanche is cheaper, why does snowball have such a following? Because paying off debt is a long behavioural task as well as a maths problem.
In a 2012 study in the Journal of Marketing Research, Gal and McShane analysed data from a debt-settlement company and found that the more of their debt accounts people closed early on, the more likely they were to eliminate their debt. They described this as a “small victories” effect. A 2011 study by Amar and colleagues looked at the opposite instinct: people tended to focus on closing small accounts even when it was not optimal, and the authors argued this “debt account aversion” can cost money. Together the findings say two things. Closing accounts is motivating. And motivation alone can lead you to pay more than necessary.
Neither study shows that snowball always wins in the real world, and neither shows that a cheaper plan is pointless. What they suggest is that the plan you complete beats the plan that is optimal on paper and abandoned in month 14.
How to choose
- Choose avalanche if your rates are far apart (for example a 29% store card next to a 6% loan), you are motivated by the numbers, and the highest-rate debt is not enormous.
- Choose snowball if you have many small balances, you have started and stopped before, or you need visible progress to keep going. The cost is often modest.
- Check the gap first. Run both on your real numbers. If the difference is $40 and you will feel better closing accounts, take snowball. If it is $900, think harder.
- Hybrid. Clear one or two tiny balances first for momentum, then switch to highest rate first. Nothing about either method forbids it.
Whatever you pick, look at the interest rates first. Credit card rates have been above 20 percent in recent Federal Reserve releases, so cards usually sit at the top of an avalanche list. A debt at 4 percent should never be the one you rush to clear before a card at 25 percent, unless there is another reason, such as a lender who will report you for a missed payment.
Mistakes that matter more than the method
- Skipping minimums. Missing a minimum triggers fees and can raise your rate. Always pay every minimum first.
- Not rolling payments forward. When a debt clears, keep paying that amount. The freed-up payment is the engine of both methods.
- New charges on a cleared card. A plan only works if balances are not refilled.
- No cushion. A small emergency fund stops one surprise bill from pushing you back onto a card.
- Ignoring a promotional rate. A 0% period changes the best order while it lasts. See the guide on a 0% balance transfer payoff plan.
Where Duedown fits
Duedown shows your debt-free date for snowball and avalanche side by side, with a what-if slider for extra payments, so you can see the real cost of each choice on your own debts. The free plan covers up to three debts; comparison across any number of debts is part of Pro. The calculators on this site use the same engine and are free.
Try it on your own debts. The debt snowball calculator and avalanche calculator are free and private. Duedown for iPhone turns the same plan into a date you can watch move.
Frequently asked questions
Is the debt snowball or avalanche better?
Avalanche costs the least interest. Snowball can cost a little more but clears accounts sooner. The better method is the one you will keep following.
Can I switch methods halfway?
Yes. Nothing locks you in. Some people start with snowball for a few quick wins, then switch to avalanche for the larger balances.
Do snowball and avalanche ever give the same result?
Yes, whenever your smallest balance also has the highest interest rate, or when your rates are all equal. Then both methods target the same debts in the same order.
Sources
- Gal and McShane (2012), Can Small Victories Help Win the War? Journal of Marketing Research
- Amar, Ariely, Ayal, Cryder and Rick (2011), Winning the Battle but Losing the War: The Psychology of Debt Management, Journal of Marketing Research
- Federal Reserve, Consumer Credit G.19 (current credit card interest rates)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, credit card tools